Review corrections on the first draft (caught by /simplify-code before
merge — the PR was disarmed for these):
- BLOCKER: --ignored=all is not a valid git mode (git exits 128 'Invalid
ignored mode'); with it, every ZIP update was refused as 'could not
check the working tree'. The mocked tests could not see this — a new
real-git test creates an actual repo + .gitignore and asserts the guard
runs clean, blocks on an ignored user file, and exempts ignored
preserved entries. --ignored=matching also reports an ignored dir as
one line instead of enumerating its contents.
- FAIL-OPEN HOLE: the ' -> ' two-path split now applies only to R/C
rename/copy status codes. Porcelain v1 does not quote plain filenames
with spaces, so an ignored file literally named 'venv -> node_modules'
parsed as two preserved tops and slipped past the guard into the
destructive swap.
- _update_via_zip's swap loop now consumes _ZIP_PRESERVED_TOP_LEVEL
instead of a comment-synced duplicate set (change-detector test added).
Carried from #87392 (closed as superseded — its core guard landed via the
#87327 salvage chain): the dirty-tree check now passes --ignored=all, so a
gitignored-but-real user file (logs, scratch files, local data) blocks the
destructive ZIP overlay too. The ZIP path's own preserved top-level entries
(venv, node_modules, .git, .env — gitignored on every normal install) are
exempted so they don't become a false refusal.
Credit: @JoaoMarcos44, whose #87392 included this hardening.
Surgical reapply of PR #87878 (@kshitijk4poor's salvage of #87327 by
@liruixinch) onto current main — the receipt-boundary and summary
changes from this session made the original commits conflict.
- ZIP fallback now keys on git ACTUALLY having failed
(_should_zip_fallback_on_update_error): a dependency-install failure
after a successful pull can't be fixed by re-downloading source and
would clobber the tree (#87331 cascade trigger, #87304).
- _abort_zip_update_if_dirty_tree: refuse to overlay a dirty checkout
(-uall so user gitconfig can't blind the guard) + pre-swap TOCTOU
re-check with our own staging artifacts filtered (#91962, #87304).
- Failure-stage naming (_format_update_failure_stage) + stderr tail so
'Git update failed' stops mislabeling pip/uv failures.
- Receipt finalize preserved on the no-fallback failure path.
Co-authored-by: kshitijk4poor <82637225+kshitijk4poor@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: liruixinch <liruixinch@outlook.com>
Teknium