Files
hermes-agent/agent/surface_switch.py
T
kshitijk4poor 6cc177a76c refactor(agent): surface-switch note lives in its own sibling; skip it where no sidecar exists
Move the six surface-switch helpers out of the conversation_loop facade
into agent/surface_switch.py (AGENTS.md: new behaviour goes in a topical
sibling), and fold the review findings on #104494:

- MoA and codex_app_server turns never stamp the api_content sidecar, so
  the staged note could not be read back from the transcript and was
  re-sent on every turn after a switch. Those modes now skip the note
  (stored prompt still reused).
- The announced surface was parsed with split(".") — a plugin platform
  with a dot in its name would never compare equal and re-stage the note
  every turn. The note now closes the name with a fixed terminator.
- One identity-line parser (identity_line_value) shared by
  _stored_prompt_matches_runtime and the switch detector instead of two
  copies of the runtime-boundary/rpartition logic; tool names via the
  existing tools.mcp_tool_agent._def_name; the transcript scan is bounded
  to the last 200 rows (it ran every turn over the whole history).
- consume_surface_switch_note reduced to a plain pop; developer-guide
  prompt-assembly.md updated (Platform is no longer an identity field);
  17 new tests trimmed to 10 (same-shape pin/retire variants folded).

Restoring Platform as an identity field still turns 5 tests red.
2026-09-09 10:31:26 +05:30

139 lines
7.2 KiB
Python

"""Surface switch without a prompt rebuild (#104414).
A surface switch (desktop <-> TUI, a session resumed under a different host) changes only which
interface renders the reply, but the surface guidance and the ``Platform:`` trailer are embedded
in the persisted system prompt. Rebuilding for it diverged the prompt within its first blocks,
so the ENTIRE request behind it re-prefilled — a 220K-token session came back at a 1% cache hit.
The stored bytes are therefore kept and the CURRENT surface's guidance is delivered on the
per-turn user-message channel instead: that lands after the cached prefix and is stamped into
the byte-stable ``api_content`` sidecar so later turns replay it unchanged. The prompt itself
converges at the next rebuild boundary (compaction).
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import logging
from typing import Any, Iterator, List
from agent.prompt_builder import RUNTIME_ENVIRONMENT_END, RUNTIME_ENVIRONMENT_HEADING
logger = logging.getLogger("run_agent")
_SURFACE_SWITCH_NOTE_PREFIX = "[System: This conversation is now being answered on a different interface: "
# Closes the surface name in the note; platform names are free-form for plugin platforms, so the
# terminator (not ".") delimits the parse.
_SURFACE_NAME_END = " — any earlier interface guidance"
# Only the newest note matters, and the note is re-stamped on the switch turn, so a bounded tail
# scan is enough; without a bound every turn of a never-switched session walks the whole transcript.
_NOTE_SCAN_TAIL = 200
def identity_line_value(prompt: str, label: str) -> str:
"""Last ``Label: value`` line in the authoritative identity portion of a persisted prompt.
Legacy prose may quote the runtime heading, but only the new renderer ENDS in the boundary;
the final runtime block is embedder prose, never identity, so it is excluded when present.
Last match wins — safe only for volatile-tier trailer fields at the end of the prompt."""
identity, runtime_marker, _ = prompt.rpartition(f"\n\n{RUNTIME_ENVIRONMENT_HEADING}\n\n")
runtime_marker = runtime_marker if prompt.endswith(RUNTIME_ENVIRONMENT_END) else ""
prefix = f"{label}:"
matches = [
line[len(prefix):].strip()
for line in (identity if runtime_marker else prompt).splitlines()
if line.startswith(prefix)
]
return matches[-1] if matches else ""
def _transcript_row_texts(msg: Any) -> Iterator[str]:
"""Every string the model actually saw for one transcript row: the wire sidecar first, then
the stored content (plain string, or the text parts of a multimodal list — where the note
lands as a durable text part because a list cannot take the string sidecar)."""
if not isinstance(msg, dict):
return
sidecar = msg.get("api_content")
if isinstance(sidecar, str):
yield sidecar
content = msg.get("content")
if isinstance(content, str):
yield content
elif isinstance(content, list):
for part in content:
if isinstance(part, dict) and isinstance(part.get("text"), str):
yield part["text"]
def _last_announced_surface(conversation_history: Any) -> str:
"""The surface named by the NEWEST switch note in the transcript ("" when none).
Once a switch has been announced, that note — not the stored prompt's ``Platform:`` trailer —
is the last thing the model was told it runs on. Reading it back is also what keeps a fresh
AIAgent per turn (the gateway shape) from stacking one copy of the note per turn."""
for msg in reversed((conversation_history or [])[-_NOTE_SCAN_TAIL:]):
for text in _transcript_row_texts(msg):
if _SURFACE_SWITCH_NOTE_PREFIX in text:
tail = text.rsplit(_SURFACE_SWITCH_NOTE_PREFIX, 1)[1]
return tail.split(_SURFACE_NAME_END, 1)[0].strip()
return ""
def _agent_tool_names(agent: Any) -> List[str]:
from tools.mcp_tool_agent import _def_name
return [name for name in map(_def_name, getattr(agent, "tools", None) or []) if name]
def note_inert_pinned_tools(agent: Any, built_for_this_surface: List[str]) -> None:
"""Name, at the end of the staged note, the pinned tools THIS surface did not build.
The freeze keeps a previous surface's tools on the wire deliberately — removing them is the one
thing that would still re-prefill the request behind the preserved prompt — so the model has
to be TOLD they are inert here, or it plans around a ``focus_pane`` a terminal turn can only
answer with ``tool_error("desktop only")``."""
surface_names = set(built_for_this_surface)
inert = [name for name in _agent_tool_names(agent) if name not in surface_names]
note = getattr(agent, "_surface_switch_note", "") or ""
if not inert or not note:
return
agent._surface_switch_note = note + (
"\n[System: These tools stay listed for this conversation (dropping them would discard "
"the cached request prefix) but were not loaded for this interface — expect a call to "
f"one of them to fail: {', '.join(inert)}.]"
)
def stage_surface_switch_note(agent: Any, prompt: str, conversation_history: Any) -> bool:
"""Stage a one-shot correction when the request would otherwise misdescribe the surface.
Compares the runtime surface against what the model was last told — the newest switch note
if one exists, else ``prompt``'s own ``Platform:`` trailer. Consulting the note matters in
both directions: switching BACK to the prompt's surface (desktop -> tui -> desktop) leaves the
trailer agreeing with the runtime while a stale note still says otherwise, and a rebuild for
an unrelated reason (a model switch) refreshes the prompt but not that note. The full surface
guidance is attached only when the prompt itself is out of date; otherwise the note just
retires the stale one. Returns whether it staged.
MoA and codex_app_server turns never stamp the ``api_content`` sidecar, so the note could not
be read back and would be re-sent every turn; those modes keep the stored prompt and skip the
note entirely."""
if getattr(agent, "provider", None) == "moa" or getattr(agent, "api_mode", None) == "codex_app_server":
return False
current = str(getattr(agent, "platform", "") or "").strip()
described = identity_line_value(prompt, "Platform")
told = _last_announced_surface(conversation_history) or described
if not current or not told or told == current:
return False
from agent.system_prompt import platform_surface_hint
hint = platform_surface_hint(agent) if described != current else ""
where = "the guidance below" if hint else "the interface section in the system prompt above"
note = (
f"{_SURFACE_SWITCH_NOTE_PREFIX}{current}{_SURFACE_NAME_END} in this conversation is "
f"superseded — follow {where} for formatting, file delivery and any interface-specific "
"capability.]"
)
agent._surface_switch_note = f"{note}\n{hint}" if hint else note
logger.info(
"Session %s switched surface %s -> %s; keeping the stored system prompt and delivering "
"the new surface guidance as a turn note (prefix cache preserved).",
agent.session_id, told, current,
)
return True